Data · dataset · 2022
Public consultation in the evaluation of animal research protocols
Listed in Borealis and Agri-environmental Research Data Dataverse — shown once because both records carry DOI 10.5683/sp3/hwg5fc
In this study we invited public responses to five different research projects, using non-technical summaries intended for lay audiences.
Description
Our aim was to assess the potential for this type of public consultation in protocol review, and a secondary aim was to better understand what types of animal research people are willing to accept and why. US participants (n = 1521) were asked (via an online survey) “Do you support the use of these (insert species) for this research”, and responded using a seven-point scale (1 = “No”, 4 = “Neutral”, and 7 = “Yes”).
Participants were asked to explain the reasons for their choice; open-ended text responses were subjected to thematic analysis. Most participants (89.7%) provided clear comments, showing the potential of an online forum to elicit feedback. Four themes were prevalent in participant reasoning regarding their support for the proposed research: 1) impact on animals, 2) impact on humans, 3) scientific merit, and 4) availability of alternatives.
Read the rest (2 more)
Participant support for the proposed research varied but on average was close to neutral (mean ± SD: 4.5 ± 2.19) suggesting some ambivalence to this animal use. The protocol describing Parkinson’s research (on monkeys) was least supported (3.9 ± 2.17) and the transplant research (on pigs) was most supported (4.9 ± 2.02). These results indicate that public participants are sensitive to specifics of a protocol.
We conclude that an online forum can provide meaningful public input on proposed animal research, offering research institutions the opportunity for improved transparency and the chance to reduce the risk that they engage in studies that are out of step with community values.
Links
Where it is published
- Dataverse dataset page borealisdata.ca/dataset.xhtml?persistentId=doi%3A10.5683%2FSP3%2FHWG5FC ↗
landing page · from borealisdata ca
- DOI doi.org/10.5683/sp3/hwg5fc ↗
DOI / persistent id · from borealisdata ca
Catalogue records · 1
- Dataverse API borealisdata.ca/api/datasets/:persistentId/?persistentId=doi%3A10.5683%2FSP3%2… ↗
metadata API · from borealisdata ca
Topics
- Stated by source
- Social Sciences · Social Sciences
Provenance · 2 source records, 22 field assertions
| Source | Key | Last seen | Raw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Borealis | doi:10.5683/SP3/HWG5FC | 12 d ago | JSON v1 |
| Agri-environmental Research Data Dataverse | doi:10.5683/SP3/HWG5FC | 11 d ago | JSON v1 |
| Field | Assertion | Extractor | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| concepts[field].anzsrc:group:3109 | enrichment · borealisdata ca | taxonomy-embedding@1.0.0 | title+keywords+description (70%) |
| concepts[field].dataverse_subject:social-sciences | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].dataverse_subject:social-sciences | source · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:chemistry | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:computer-science-ai | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:earth-environmental | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:economics-finance | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:engineering | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:humanities | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:life-sciences | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:mathematics-statistics | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:medicine-health | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:ocean-atmospheric | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:social-science | mapping · borealisdata ca dataverse | connector:borealisdata_ca_dataverse@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[field].local:field:social-science | mapping · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | /subjects |
| concepts[modality].local:modality:text | enrichment · borealisdata ca | keyword-concept-rules@1.0.0 | title+description (75%) |
| created_date | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | |
| description | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | /description |
| publication_date | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | |
| title | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | /name |
| updated_date | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 | |
| version_label | source · borealisdata ca | connector:borealisdata_ca@1.0.0 |